Tuesday, August 06, 2019
The North American Orthodox-Catholic Theological Consultation has released a new agreed statement entitled, The Vocation and Mission of the People of God: “A Chosen Race, a Royal Priesthood, a Holy Nation”.
The document was finalized at the most recent meeting of the
Consultation which took place in late May of this year at the Saint
Methodios Faith and Heritage Center in Contoocook, New Hampshire. The
Consultation is co-chaired by Cardinal Joseph W. Tobin, the Catholic
Archbishop of Newark, and by Greek Orthodox Metropolitan Methodios of
Boston.
More than five years in the making, this new text takes a different
approach to ecumenical dialogue: instead of addressing together an issue
that has prevented full communion between the churches, here the
Catholic and Orthodox theologians examine together challenges that
affect both churches, in this case the role of the laity in the two
traditions and the problem of clericalism.
The document begins with a summary of earlier statements by the
Consultation on these and similar themes. It goes on to recognize an
ecclesiology that sees the sacrament of Baptism as the foundation of the
vocation and ministry of every Christian, clergy and laity alike. Thus
all the People of God together constitute a single community. Some
members have received a special role of leadership within the community,
but all of the members have received specific charisms that are to be
exercised for the building up of the whole body. Within this context,
the ordained clergy are set apart from the body of believers but are not
above or separate from that body. All of this is expressed most clearly
in the celebration of the Eucharist where the diversity of gifts and
roles is made clear in the gathered community’s single act of praise.
The document goes on to reflect on the mission of the laity in the
Church, and the implications of this ecclesiology for the practice of
synodality at all levels of the Church’s life. In a final section, the
agreed statement considers certain challenges to the People of God,
namely clericalism, individualism and ecumenical engagement. The
Consultation concludes that “our focus in thinking about the Church, and
in celebrating its reality, must be on the unity of the People of God
that is grounded in our common baptism and on a corresponding
understanding of the diversity of roles and charisms within that
radically united people.”
Like most dialogue agreed statements, this new text does not speak
officially for either Church. However, it has been drafted by a highly
competent group of theologians from both traditions and submitted to all
the members of both Churches for their prayerful reflection and
discussion. The full text of the statement can be found here.
The North American Orthodox-Catholic Theological Consultation is
sponsored jointly by the Assembly of Canonical Orthodox Bishops of the
United States of America the Bishops' Committee for Ecumenical and
Interreligious Affairs of the USCCB, and the Canadian Conference of
Catholic Bishops. Since its establishment in 1965, the Consultation has
issued some 30 agreed statements on various topics. All these texts are
available on the website of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops at: http://www.usccb.org/beliefs-and-teachings/ecumenical-and-interreligious/ecumenical/orthodox/index.cfm and on the web site of the Orthodox Assembly of Bishops at http://www.assemblyofbishops.org/ministries/orthodox-catholic/
Another body, the Joint Committee of Orthodox and Catholic Bishops,
has been meeting annually since 1981 to discuss pastoral issues between
the two churches.
The North American Orthodox-Catholic Theological Consultation
The Vocation and Mission of the People of God:
"A Chosen Race, a Royal Priesthood, a Holy Nation"
But you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God's
own people, that you may declare the wonderful deeds of him who called
you out of darkness into his marvelous light. Once you were no people;
once you had not received mercy but now you have received mercy. (I
Peter 2:9-10)
Our Lord Jesus Christ continues to call individuals to be his
disciples, members of the "holy nation" we call his Church. From the day
of Pentecost, this saving relationship with Christ has normally been
established through the solemn and joyous event of baptism and the gift
of the Holy Spirit. A sacred rite, rich with deep significance -
baptism, in water and in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy
Spirit - ultimately proclaims that the newly baptized is united to
Christ and his people, participates in his death and resurrection,
personally receives the gift of the Spirit, and comes to know the
generous love of the Father expressed in the forgiveness of sin. Through
these new relationships, the believer now lives as a member of the Body
of Christ (1 Cor 12:27), God's faithful people - a life which is
manifested especially in the celebration of Holy Eucharist. He or she is
now a member of the Church which is "a chosen race, a royal priesthood,
a holy nation, God's own people."
These words from the Epistle of Peter immediately point to the value
and dignity of every member of the Church. Baptism marks the beginning
of a new life of holiness and discipleship in Christ. Each member has
been fully united to him, is blessed with the gifts of the Spirit, and
so is bound through Christ to other believers. Each one now has a public
mission: to "declare the wonderful deeds" of God the Father, who "calls
us out of darkness into his marvelous light."
So we reaffirm what we agreed almost twenty years ago, solemnly
recognizing the validity of sacramental initiation in each other's
communities: "The Orthodox and Catholic churches both teach the same
understanding of baptism. This identical teaching draws on the same
sources in Scripture and Tradition, and it has not varied in any
significant way from the very earliest witnesses to the faith up to the
present day. A central element in this single teaching is the conviction
that baptism comes to us as God's gift in Christ, through the Holy
Spirit. It is therefore not 'of us,' but from above."[1]
In this present Agreed Statement, the members of the North American
Orthodox-Catholic Consultation want first to affirm the vocation and
ministry of each member of the Church: a vocation and a ministry rooted
in Christ's call, first given through baptism and chrismation, and lived
out through the relationships, responsibilities and obligations each of
us encounters in daily life, in family, Church and society.
Over the past four years, our earlier, continuing examination of the
dimensions of primacy and conciliarity or synodality in the life of the
Church has led us also to study the People of God, who are that Church
in its fullness.[2]
In the past, we responded to the Lima document on Baptism, Eucharist
and Ministry in 1984, and spoke more at length about the significance of
baptism in both of our Churches in our Statement on "Baptism and
Sacramental Economy" (1999). We have also briefly spoken of the laity in
our early Statement on "The Church" (1974) and in our Statement on
"Conciliarity and Primacy" (1989). We also referred to the distinctive
vocation of the Christian laity in our Statement, "Steps towards a
Reunited Church: A Sketch of an Orthodox-Catholic Vision for the Future"
(2010). The International Orthodox-Catholic dialogue, too, in 2007,
made a number of valuable references to the specific participation of
the laity in the life of the Church in its Statement, "Ecclesiological
and Canonical Consequences of the Sacramental Nature of the Church:
Ecclesial Communion, Conciliarity and Authority" (The "Ravenna
Statement," 2007) and our Consultation responded to that Statement in
2009.
We believe, however, that discussion of the basic constitution of the
Church, and of the specific role of the laity, remains somewhat
underdeveloped in our previous statements, as well as in the statements
of the International Commission. On the one hand, the topic has not been
a 'church-dividing' issue between Orthodoxy and Catholicism. Rather, in
both our Churches in recent decades there have been continuing
discussions about the proper role of the laity in worship,
administration and witness. So the Second Vatican Council, in its
Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy, expressed the Catholic Church's
desire "that all believers be brought to that full, conscious, and
active participation in liturgical celebrations which is required by the
nature of the liturgy itself and to which the Christian people… have,
in virtue of baptism, a right and a duty." (Sacrosanctum Concilium 14)
Second, we recognize that both of our churches have often been
affected by a strong emphasis on the vocation and ministry of the
clergy, even to the neglect of the ministry of the laity. A lay person
has frequently been assumed, as in I Clement, simply to be one who is not ordained (see
above, n. 2). This perspective appears to neglect the proper, wider
vocation of every Christian disciple, as that is rooted in Christ's call
and in baptism.
We have come, therefore, to recognize the need to articulate together
a common perspective on the People of God and the vocation and ministry
of lay persons and the ordained within it, especially in light of
contemporary challenges both in the Church and in society. From the
beginning of our Consultation in 1965, lay theologians, both women and
men, have been full and active participants. We gratefully affirm their
contributions, and believe that our North American Consultation can take
a distinctive part in this important discussion. It is in that spirit
that we respectfully submit this statement to our churches.
I. The Mystery of Baptism
Baptism, as the central act of Christian initiation, is a rite rich
in significance. At its heart are two fundamental affirmations. First,
baptism, celebrated with water in the name of the Father, the Son, and
the Holy Spirit and completed by chrismation and the reception of the
Eucharist, brings about our union with God in Christ and our sharing in
Christ's death and resurrection. It is the act that marks the beginning
of every distinctively Christian life; so, with the Apostle Paul, we
affirm: "As many of you who have been baptized in Christ have put on
Christ" (Gal.3:27).
Second, baptism thus marks our entry into the Church, which is the People of God.
Our mysterious union with Christ our Lord through baptism is, at the
same time, a union with all those who are 'in Christ' (Phil.1:1). If
Christ is the head, then the Church is his Body (Col. 1:18). The two
share one life. For every believer, growth in holiness takes place both
through our relationship with Christ and through our sharing this
relationship with fellow members of the Church.
As we have previously said: "Baptism is not a human work, but the
rebirth from above, effected through 'water and the Spirit,' that
introduces us into the life of the Church. It is that gift by which God
grounds and establishes the Church as the community of the New Covenant,
the 'Israel of God' (Gal 6:16), by engrafting us into the body of the
crucified and risen Messiah (Rom 6:3-11; 11:17-24), into the one
sacrament (mysterion) which is Christ himself (Eph 1:3; 3:3; Col 1:27 and 2:2)."[3]
A number of the Fathers, both Eastern and Western, have spoken about
Christ's saving work in terms of his three "offices": of Priest, Prophet
and King. As priest, Christ is the one who offers himself up for the
salvation of the world. As prophet, he is the one who proclaims the
truth to us about God and the human person. As king, he is the one who
leads his faithful people to the Father.
The same Fathers of the Church also remind us that, through baptism,
the faithful themselves share in these offices of Christ. So St. John
Chrysostom says: "Through baptism, you have become king, and priest and
prophet: a king, in that you have dashed to earth all the deeds of
wickedness and slain your sins; a priest, in that you offer yourself to
God; a prophet, knowing what shall be, and being inspired by God and
sealed." (Homily 3:4-5 on II Cor)
A prayer from the Roman rite of baptism, accompanying the "sealing"
of a newly baptized person with sacred chrism, says: "God, the Father of
our Lord Jesus Christ, has freed you from sin, given you a new birth by
water and the Holy Spirit, and welcomed you into his holy people. He
now anoints you with the chrism of salvation. As Christ was anointed
Priest, Prophet, and King, so may you live always as a member of his
body, sharing everlasting life."
Our understanding of the fundamental vocation and ministry of all
Christian men and women is rooted in the call of Christ as it is
manifested in the sacrament of baptism. By this sacred rite, we are
bound to the Lord and his people, and blessed with the gifts of his
Spirit.
II. The People of God
The people of God are distinguished both by charisms (1 Cor 12:7;
14:26), or interior gifts, and by public ministries; both of these serve
to build up the community. The New Testament mentions distinctive roles
of leadership in the community, such as ministers (I Cor 4.1; 2
Cor 3.6; 6.4), presidents (Rom 12.8; I Thes 5.12; Heb 13.7, 17, 24; Acts
12.1; 20.28), pastors (Eph 4.11), elders (Tit 1.5), and teachers (Acts
12.1; I Cor 12.28) as gifts of the Spirit, given to some individuals in
the community for the sake of all. The charisms of all the
baptized, above and beyond these special roles, are linked with their
participation in the prophetic, priestly and kingly role of Christ,
enabling all to be witnesses to him through lives of faith. "The
manifestation of the Spirit received by each person," St. Paul reminds
us, "is given for the common good" (1 Cor 12:7). But all these charisms
"equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of
Christ, until all of us come to the unity of faith and of the knowledge
of the Son of God, to maturity, to the measure of the full stature of
Christ" (Eph 4.11-12) The diverse ministries carried out in the Church
are all forms of service, the focus being on our common mission rather
than on anyone's particular identity.
Reflection beginning with the people of God as a whole, then, rather
than with the notion of "the laity" as distinct from "the clergy,"
replaces the "priesthood-laity" divide with an emphasis on the necessity
of all ministries for "the building up of the Body of Christ," as that
Body serves the world. A genuinely dialogical Church, formed from these
ministries, is thus characterized by mutual listening, mutual
witnessing, and mutual respect, as well as by distinctions in office and
function. Ecclesial structures, such as bishops' synods and regional or
ecumenical councils, maintain and foster the unity in faith of the Body
of Christ.
The terms "a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God's
own people" apply to all the baptized, before there are further
distinctions within the community, and emphasize the unitary nature of
the community, founded on a common baptism and common confirmation or
chrismation. The people addressed in I Peter 2.9-10 are therefore not
the "laity," but the faithful Christian people. According to I Peter,
the spiritual rebirth of Christians occurs through the resurrection of
Christ, in which Christians share through baptism and chrismation (see
Rom 6:3-11). This is the basic identity that defines all groupings
within the community, whether those groups be identified as the laity,
the clergy, monks, or religious.
Every member of the Church has a dignity and value rooted in baptism.
The Spirit also endows each baptized Christian with spiritual gifts,
which are meant to contribute to the well-being of the Body and to the
salvation of the world. While these spiritual gifts serve to highlight
each person's unique identity, they are not meant to harm the bond of
unity which each baptized person has with the rest in Christ (1 Cor.
12:4-11). Each gift is given, ultimately, not for the benefit of any one
person alone, but for the well-being of all the members of the Body of
Christ. As St. Basil the Great says: "We are all members one of another,
having different gifts according to the grace of God which has been
given to us…All the members together make up the Body of Christ in the
unity of the Spirit, and render to one another the necessary service
according to their gifts" (On the Holy Spirit, 26).
Baptism and Orders
Among the many particular gifts of the Spirit, some persons are
appointed to exercise a special leadership role within the community, as
bishops, priests and deacons. Both Orthodox and Catholics affirm that
these orders are essential to the life of the Church. Yet, the ordained
ministry is itself but one of the many gifts of the Spirit to the
Church. The differentiation between clergy and laity itself rests on a
gift, which serves as the basis for liturgical ministry. Those who are
called to the ordained ministry continue to be fellow members of the
Body of Christ and People of God, together with all who are baptized.
At the same time, the gift of ordained ministry itself builds the
distinctive relationship between the one ordained and the other members
of the Eucharistic community. Each ordained minister is involved in a
special ministry of service "for the building up of the Body of Christ"
(Eph. 4:12). So St. John Chrysostom says to the clergy: "If lay people
need us, in the same way we as ministers exist for their sake, appointed
for their spiritual needs. We need each other: the leaders need the
support of the people and those in office equally need the contribution
of the flock. To be a leader implies that persons be taken care of and
be helped. Nobody exists as self-sufficient, assuming that he himself
can do all. …Therefore, the Church as a conciliar assembly can do much
more than one single person. All that one person alone cannot do,
rather, he or she can do together with others." (Homily 30 on 1 Corinthians, 7)
So we speak of the clergy as being "set apart," but not as "above" or
separate from the body of believers. Indeed, it could be also said that
every baptized believer is "set apart" to serve God in the Church and
in wider human society. This means that the clergy are called to serve
the other members of the community with the gift of the Spirit in a
distinctive manner, which is sanctioned and blessed by the Church itself
through the rites of election and ordination. Yet the fact that every
ordination takes place within the context of the community's Eucharist,
and with the assent of the community, reminds us that an ordained person
is intimately related to the entire Body of the Church. God calls the
one who is ordained from the midst of the Church for the service of the
Church.
There is always a profound, intimate connection, then, between those
who are ordained and those to whom and with whom their ministry is
offered. St. Augustine expressed this reciprocal relationship when he
boldly declared: "Although I am terrified by what I am for you, I am
consoled by what I am with you. For you, I am your bishop; with you I am
a Christian. The former is a title of an office which has been
undertaken, the latter is a title of grace. The first is a danger, the
second salvation…Precisely as we struggle in this office we find rest in
the common good…. It consoles me more that I have been redeemed with
you than that I have been placed over you…Aid us by your prayers and
your obedience, that we may rejoice not so much in overseeing you as in
serving you." (Sermon 340:1)
The Eucharistic Community
This intimate relationship of the bishop and priest with the laity is
most clearly expressed each time the Church gathers to celebrate the
Eucharist. The bishop or priest who presides at the Eucharist represents
Christ as the head of the Church, which is his body. As president of
the Eucharistic assembly, it is the bishop's or priest's responsibility
to preside before the altar, to proclaim the Gospel, to preach and
interpret the word of God, to receive and offer the bread and wine, and
to intone the great Eucharistic prayer.
At the same time, the Eucharist is not the action of the bishop or
priest alone, separated from the community. Rather, the Eucharist is,
properly speaking, the priestly act of the entire People of God,
gathered at a particular place in obedience to the Lord's command to do
this in his memory (1 Cor.11:24). So all the members of the assembly
truly celebrate the Eucharist, led by the bishop or priest. The prayers
of the Eucharistic liturgy, in both our traditions, are normally
addressed to God in the first-person plural, because they are rightfully
the community's words; so while the bishop or priest speaks the prayers
aloud, all the members of the community give their assent by responding
together "Amen." While the bishop or priest offers the bread and wine,
as the Byzantine liturgy expresses it, "on behalf of all and for all,"
it is the faithful who present these gifts to be offered. All respond to
his greeting, "The Lord be with you," by replying "And with your
Spirit," confirming their conviction that he presides by the grace of
the Holy Spirit, given in ordination; all exchange the 'kiss of peace'
and profess with the presider their common faith. And while the bishop
or priest is the first to receive the Holy Communion, all the members
partake of the same bread and the same cup. In these liturgical actions,
the synodal or conciliar structure of the Church is expressed in a way
which does not deny or diminish the genuine primacy of the bishop or
priest.
It is within the Eucharistic context, in fact, that one can clearly
see operative the mutual relationship of clergy and laity, as well as
the principles of both primacy and conciliarity in the Church as a
whole. So St. John Chrysostom says that "during the most awe-inspiring
mysteries, the priest prays for the people and the people pray for the
priest, for the words 'with your spirit' are nothing else but that. The
offering of the Eucharist is in common, for it is not the priest alone
who gives thanks, but the whole people. He first speaks in their voice,
then they add that it is 'fitting and right' to do this. Then, the
Eucharist begins." (Homily 18 on II Corinthians 8.24). And in
another homily, he declares: "With us, all things are equal. The saving
life that sustains our souls is given with equal honor to both you and
me. I do not, after all, partake of one Lamb and you of another, but we
partake of the same. We all have the same baptism. We have been promised
the same Spirit. We are all hastening to the same Kingdom. We are all
alike brothers and sisters in Christ, sharing all things in common!" (Homily 4 on II Thessalonians 3.2 )
The image of an intimate mutual relationship of giving and receiving, modeled on the circuminsessio or perichoresis
of the Persons of the Holy Trinity, may even be apt to describe the
relationship of the various charisms, ministries, and states of life
among the faithful in the Eucharistic community. Within the diversity whose source is the Spirit of unity, all work together to build up the Body of Christ.
III. The Ministry and Mission of the Laity
While the entire people of God is called to minister in and for the church, as early as the Apostolic Tradition one
finds a distinction between clerical and lay ministries evidenced
through the distinction between the ordination of bishops, presbyters,
and deacons, through a laying-on of hands, and the simple installation
or institution of lay ministers such as widows and readers. So in both
the Orthodox and Catholic churches, liturgical ministry includes not
simply the presiders but altar servers, cantors, lectors, and the choir.
Beyond these liturgical roles, increasing numbers of lay people today
teach the faith, serve in peace and justice networks, in soup kitchens
and shelters, in administrative positions, and in various parish
programs. In the Catholic Church, for example, lay persons are regularly
involved in the liturgy as extraordinary Eucharistic ministers, and in
some places are responsible for leading Sunday worship in the absence of
a priest. In the Orthodox Church, lay persons are involved in parish,
diocesan, and national church assemblies (Clergy-Laity congresses), and
function as short-term and long-term missionaries.
Through our union with Christ in baptism, every disciple has an
obligation to be a defender of the apostolic faith through the way we
live out our relationships and responsibilities in family, Church and
society. As the recent Ravenna statement of our international
Orthodox-Catholic dialogue says: "The whole community and each person in
it bears the 'conscience of the Church' (ekklesiastike syneidesis), as Greek theology calls it - the sensus fidelium
in Latin terminology. By virtue of baptism and confirmation
(chrismation) each member of the Church exercises a form of authority in
the Body of Christ. In this sense, all the faithful (and not just the
bishops) are responsible for the faith professed at baptism. It is our
common teaching that the people of God, having received 'the anointing
which comes from the Holy One' (1 John 2, 20 and 27), in communion with
their pastors, cannot err in matters of faith (cf. John 16, 13)."[4]
The participation of the laity in councils, the consultation of the
faithful in matters of discipline and faith, and their longer-term
involvement in the reception of doctrinal definitions, so that they
become embedded in the life, worship, and teaching of the Church,
reflects the role that the whole people of God, as a single Body,
ultimately must play. Engagement in society extends to all the baptized,
insofar as all the baptized are called to participate actively and
responsibly in the church's mission of proclaiming salvation to the
whole world. All are called to share their gifts and talents in the
family, the workplace, the civic community and the parish or diocese.
Not surprisingly, it is often the laity who are best able to provide
decisive Christian witness in these settings, and within the
professional, political, and cultural life of society.
The Church has a mission to the world. The people of God are sent out
as "the light of the world" and "the salt of the earth" (Mt 5:13-14).
The relationship between the Church and the world is perhaps best
described as an interplay, an interpenetration, insofar as the Church,
along with the whole of humanity, shares the world's lot even while it
serves as a leaven within human society, renewing it in Christ, and
collaborating with Christ to transform it in conformity with the Kingdom
of God.
The whole Church's mission, then, is ultimately the transformation of
the world into the Kingdom of God. Jesus proclaimed the coming of the
Kingdom of God (Mark 1:9-15; Luke 3:21-4:14), identifying the
transformation foretold by Isaiah 61:1-2: good news brought to the poor,
captives released, the blind given sight, and the oppressed freed. The
Kingdom was revealed as present in the person and actions of Jesus (Luke
4:21). The mission of the church participates in the mission of Jesus,
manifested at his baptism and assumed by Christians in their own
baptisms, in which they put on Christ and participate in his death and
resurrection. Precisely as members of the body of Christ, all the
faithful share in the anointing of the Spirit, are formed into a holy
and royal priesthood, offer "spiritual sacrifices to God through Jesus
Christ" (I Pet 2.4-5), and have a part to play in the mission of the
body as a whole.
The church then, is a sign for the nations, and so has a mission that
encompasses both the historical reality of human community now and its
ultimate union with God. So it is oriented eschatologically, signifying
the ultimate union of all, when recapitulated in Christ at the end time.
The Church in its most basic identity, for both the Catholic and
Orthodox traditions, is thus called a sacramental reality, in which God
works actively in and through human beings and actions in the midst of a
concrete, historical community.[5]
Implications for Synodality
The identity of the whole Church, as participating in the threefold
office of Christ and as sharing in the inerrancy of the whole people of
God in matters of faith, [6]
bears implications for its conciliarity and synodality. As our own
"Agreed Statement on Conciliarity and Primacy in the Church" states,
"The ordering of charisms within the community is the basis of the
Church's structure, and the reason why permanent offices of leadership
have been divinely established with the Eucharistic body, since
apostolic times, as a service of love and a safeguard of unity in faith
and life."[7]
While the term "conciliarity" primarily refers to a gathering of
bishops exercising their pastoral office, the Ravenna document affirms
the possibility of "taking the term in a more comprehensive sense to
refer to all the members of the Church (cf. the Russian term sobornost)"
and "as signifying that each member of the Body of Christ, by virtue of
baptism, has his or her place and proper responsibility in eucharistic koinonia."[8]
The Ravenna document identifies the ultimate foundation of conciliarity
to be the Trinitarian mystery, wherein the three persons of the Trinity
are "'enumerated' without the designation as 'second' or 'third' person
implying any diminution or subordination."[9]
Similarly, an ordering among local churches does not imply any
inequality between them. While the Eucharist has rightfully been
identified as manifesting this order and koinonia within the
ecclesial community, we wish to assert here that a baptismal
ecclesiology of the people of God, endowed with various charisms,
likewise provides a theological foundation for the practice of
conciliarity.
Conciliarity is manifested in the local church gathered around its
bishop, in regional groupings of neighboring local churches, and in the
entire or whole Church (ecclesia universa).[10]
In each case, the Church is constituted by Christian believers and
their assemblies; these people, regardless of their office or state in
life, gather as synodoi, "travel companions". Synodality and
conciliarity are aspects of the life of the entire church, before they
are activities of the church's hierarchy. Consequently, synodality and
conciliarity imply in some sense the participation of all the people of
God.
The Ravenna statement identifies conciliarity primarily with the
local Church, described as "synodal" or "conciliar" in structure (§ 20),
but states that the composition of a regional synod is always
essentially episcopal: even when it includes other members of the
Church, only bishops have a deliberative voice (§ 25). Despite the
episcopal character of regional synods, their conciliarity or synodality
involves the entire Churches of the assembled bishops in two respects.
First, the bishops "are bearers of, and give voice to, the faith" of the
Churches (§ 38). Second, the decisions of a council are received
through a process "according to which the people of God as a whole—by
means of reflection, discernment, discussion and prayer—acknowledge in
these decisions the one apostolic faith of the local Churches…of which
the bishops are the teachers (didaskaloi) and the guardians" (§
37). The process of reception of the decisions of the bishops into the
life of the Churches, especially their liturgical life, is a process
which involves the entire Church.
Historical precedent for such a corporate understanding exists in the
early Church. The Acts of the Apostles reports that "the apostles and
elders met together to consider the matter" of the relation of Christian
conversion to taking on the full obligations of Jewish law (Acts 15:6),
and mentions the presence of an assembly (15:12). Local synods gathered
during Cyprian's time in the Church of Carthage "with a multitude of
faithful present" expressing their opinions.[11] At the First Ecumenical Council, laity eagerly defended the party of their choice,[12] although in later councils they were normally just represented by the Byzantine emperors and imperial officials.
A synodical and conciliar church is characterized by mutual
listening, mutual dialogue, mutual witnessing, and mutual respect.
Ecclesial events such as synods and councils become focal points for
these activities, at the same time as they exhibit the very character of
the church. As St. John Chrysostom says, "Church and Synod are
synonymous."[13]
The ideal, as articulated in the Ravenna statement, is that in a truly
synodal order there should be "neither passivity nor substitution of
functions, neither negligence nor domination of anyone by another."[14] The instinct of faith (sensus fidei), a gift of the Holy Spirit given to all the baptized, unites all the members of the church, each in his or her own proper role, in discerning the presence of the Spirit, the mind of Christ, and the will of the Father.
IV. Challenges for the People of God: Clericalism, Individualism, and Ecumenical Reunion
Expanded participation in the life of both of our Churches by lay
people still represents, to some extent, a change in normal practice for
the contemporary church. Not surprisingly, alongside the multiple
benefits an active laity provides, there continue to be tensions, in
some instances even a certain polarity between clergy and laity.
What this tension between trajectories of service has obscured is the
fact that the whole church has an unchanged mission to serve the world.
When the modern concept of a recognized lay ministry in the church
began to be explored and developed, several decades ago, it seemed to
lie somewhat outside the time-honored idea of how the church and its
offices should function. Even today, the relationship between lay
ministers and ordained clergy can be strained, as both navigate their
respective roles and identities.
"Clericalism," surely, is a problem for both our churches. Ordination
to clerical status is viewed by some as an "elevation," rather than as a
gift of new responsibilities within the body for the well-being and
ordering of the whole. Often, too, ministries in the church are
understood by promoters of lay leadership as purely functional, a "job"
for which one acquires professional qualifications, rather than as a
lasting gift of the Spirit for the sake of the community. However, a
dialogical relationship between the ordained and the non-ordained can
enhance an appreciation of the underlying equality of the baptized
faithful before God across the various charisms, ministries, and roles
within the body. As the Lord said: "If anyone would be first, he must be
last of all and servant of all." (Mk 9:35) Service to the other, in
action and in spirit, is the hallmark of Christian leadership.
So clericalism, when pushed to its extreme, brings about an
understanding of the church as constituted in a privileged way by the
ordained, and a reduction, an objectification, of the laity to
second-class status can follow. This can lead, among today's young
people, either to a world-hostile traditionalism or to the phenomenon of
"voting with your feet." Feeling alienated from the contemporary life
of the church, more and more faithful people, especially the young, have
come either to seek authentic discipleship by returning to the forms of
worship and structure they imagine were shared by their grandparents,
or else to seek to privatize their inner lives in a way inspired by
contemporary secular individualism, claiming to be "spiritual, but not
religious." For both groups, contemporary ministerial professionals and
their institution — the contemporary Church —can seem to be unnecessary,
even a hindrance to real faith.
A mutually respectful relationship between clergy and laity needs to
be strengthened in both of our Churches, by our finding an expanded,
active role for all the faithful in the conciliar and synodical
structures of the church — at the parish, diocesan, and universal levels
— so that a multiplicity of voices can be effectively heard. The ideal,
as articulated in the Ravenna statement, is that there be "neither
passivity nor substitution of functions, neither negligence nor
domination of anyone by another." It will require a restored emphasis on
the Church as constituting, in the united activity of all of its
members, the full Body of Christ, who is its head. It will also require a
spiritual renewal in all of us: new humility, a new desire to be of
genuine service, a new pursuit of Christlike holiness.
Yet the implications of such a renewal for growth towards ecumenical
unity between the Orthodox and Catholic families of Churches seem also
to be profound. All of us, after all, begin our Christian lives as lay
persons. Through baptism, we are all incorporated into the Body of
Christ, and therefore are in a relationship of communion with one
another in Christ. However, this communion, though genuine, remains
"imperfect;"[15]
as a result, the desires of many Orthodox and Catholic Christians for a
more intimate relationship of faith and religious practice, especially
through Eucharistic sharing, remains largely unfulfilled. And while it
is clearly the role of the both leaders and other members of our
Churches to act as "stewards of the mysteries of God" (I Cor 4.1; cf.
Tit 1.7), one must also ask whether a deep sense of responsibility for
the heritage we guard can also sometimes pose an obstacle to reunion.
V. Conclusion
A baptismally-based ecclesiology grounds the principle and practice
of conciliarity. The Ravenna statement describes conciliarity as
"signifying that each member of the Body of Christ by virtue of baptism,
has his or her place and proper responsibility in eucharistic koinonia (communio in Latin)."[16]
As a result of baptism and chrismation, the whole church makes up the
royal priesthood, shares in the prophetic mission of Christ in the
world, works to realize the justice and peace of his Kingdom in the
wider human community, and yearns to express this vocation in the
structured unity of Eucharistic celebration. An emphasis on the whole
people of God, as the foundation for how we conceive of the Church,
suggests that any attempt to divide the body of Christ leads ultimately
to expressing the Christian faith, too, in contrasting and negative
categories. Our focus in thinking about the Church, and in celebrating
its reality, must be on the unity of the people of God that is grounded
in our common baptism, and on a corresponding understanding of the
diversity of roles and charisms within that radically unified people.
From this renewed point of departure, we hope further insight may
emerge regarding renewed conciliar and synodical structures and
processes, which might pave the way towards deepening the unity that
already exists between our two Christian families through baptism and
chrismation. "There is one body and one Spirit," St. Paul reminds us,
"just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call: one
Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is above
all and through all and in all. But grace was given to each of us
according to the measure of Christ's gift." (Eph 4.4-7) Enlivened by
those particular gifts of God, may we continue to seek ways towards the
unity in Christ of which Paul speaks.
Contoocook, New HampshireMay 29, 2019
[1] Agreed Statement on Baptism and Sacramental Economy (1999).
[2] One often sees references that derive the word "layperson" from the biblical word laos, (laόV) meaning "the people of God" in contrast to the pagan nations. According to this view laypeople are simply those persons who belong to the people consecrated to God. If this were true, the word "lay" would be synonymous with "sacred." But such an interpretation rests on a double confusion. First, it presupposes that the word "lay" arose within primitive Christian or contemporary Jewish circles, when it fact it occurs 300 B.C. in Hellenistic papyri. The second presupposition is that the adjective "lay" is always suggestive of the noun laos, which Christians understand generally to mean "people of God." However, the noun laos, in the Bible as well as in secular texts, has a special meaning: not people in general, but the common people in so far as they are distinguished from their leaders - the equivalent of plebs.
While the Greek word laos is a biblical term that occurs frequently in Scripture, to designate the people of God in distinction from the pagan nations, the word "layperson" (laikόV) is not a biblical word. It occurs neither in the LXX nor in the New Testament, but is an ecclesiastical word that appears for the first time in the first epistle of Clement, about the year 96, to describe those members of the people of Israel who were neither priests nor Levites: "Special ministries have been assigned to the high-priest; a special place has been allotted to the priests; and the Levites have their own duties. Lay people are bound by rules laid down for the laity." Even though I Clement identifies the laity here by distinguishing them from "priests and Levites," he gives them a place within the consecrated people, who are set apart from the non-consecrated "nations". This identification as a consecrated people opens the way for an identification of the laity with the "people of God" and the "royal priesthood," that is, to identify them as being consecrated persons.
[3] Agreed Statement on Baptism and Sacramental Economy (1999).
[4] "Ecclesiological and Canonical Consequences of the Sacramental Nature of the Church: Ecclesial Communion, Conciliarity and Authority" 7 (Ravenna, October 13, 2007.)
[5] The sacramental nature of the church is affirmed in the Ravenna statement, "Ecclesiological and Canonical Consequences of the Sacramental Nature of the Church: Ecclesial Communion, Conciliarity and Authority," Ravenna, 13 October 2007.
[6] Lumen gentium, 12; on the instinct of a baptized Christian to discern the truth in Scripture, see Irenaeus, Against Heresies, 1.9.4, PG 7.545.
[7] Orthodox-Catholic Theological Consultation, "An Agreed Statement on Conciliarity and Primacy in the Church," October, 1989, § 5. http://www.usccb.org/beliefs-and-teachings/ecumenical-and-interreligious/ecumenical/orthodox/conciliarity-and-primacy.cfm.
[8] Joint International Commission for the Theological Dialogue Between the Roman Catholic church and the Orthodox Church, "Ecclesiological and Canonical Consequences of the Sacramental Nature of the Church: Ecclesial Communion, Conciliarity and Authority (Ravenna, 12 October 2007), § 5.
[9] Ibid.
[10] Ibid., §§ 10, 17.
[11] Cyprian, Epistle, 13:31; PL 4.267, 3093, 320, cited by John N. Karmiris, The Status and Ministry of the Laity in the Orthodox Church (Brookline, Mass.: Holy Cross, 1994), 14.
[12] Socrates, Ecclesiastical History, 1.8; PG 67.64, referenced by Karmiris, Status and Ministry of the Laity, 14.
[13] Saint John Chrysostom, Explicatio in Ps. 149.
[14] Ibid., § 21.
[15] See Vatican II, Unitatis Redintegratio 3.
[16] Ravenna document 5 (2007)