Detail of 12th-century stained glass fragment depicting an angel
appearing to a deacon saint, Clermont-Ferrand, France (Metropolitan
Museum of Art)
Overall I was more encouraged than discouraged by Pope Francis's May 10 discussion about women deacons at the triennial meeting of the Union of International Superiors General.
I was pleasantly surprised that the pope was considering a
"sacramental decree" about the issue. My worst fear was that church
officials would establish an ahistorical hybrid "deaconette" function
for women that was neither fish nor fowl — neither ordained nor lay.
Instead, it appears that Francis seeks a "solid theological, historical
foundation" to sacramentally ordain women deacons.
This is where the discouraging part comes in.
The solid historical foundation is already there. In spades.
There is ample historical evidence that women ministered as deacons
for 12 centuries — from the first-century Phoebe, whom Paul identifies
in Roman 16:1 as a diakonos, the same word he uses to describe
his own ministry (1 Corinthians 3:5 and 2 Corinthians 6:4) — to the
12th-century French theologian and deacon, Heloise.
History is not the sticking point. The sticking point
seems to be theological, with the disagreement centering around the
anachronistic red herring of sacramentality.
This is irritating since the theological recognition of
sacramentality — the ability of the material world to mediate the sacred
— didn't begin to develop until the Middle Ages — much later than the
coequal leadership modelled in the first century church where Paul names
Prisca and her husband Aquila as his "coworkers in the Gospel," and
Junia and her husband Andronicus as "outstanding among the apostles"
(Romans 16:3-4,7).
In our earliest history, both women and men preached the Gospel,
served as missionaries, prophets and patrons, baptized, taught
Scripture, founded and led house churches, and presided at eucharistic
celebrations in their house-church communities.
All Christians were understood to image Christ: "There is no longer
Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male
and female; for all of you are one in Christ Jesus," as Paul reminds us
in the beautiful Galatian baptismal hymn (3:28).
So what happened? A struggle with the larger patriarchal culture is what happened.
Jesus' seminal egalitarian vision was attractive to both women and
men. Both were inspired and empowered to publicly evangelize and preach
Good News through their domestic and business networks.
But women's public exercise of ecclesial authority was unsettling to
the mainstream Greco-Roman culture, which saw it as a violation of
gendered understandings of public and domestic space. When Prisca taught
the male disciple Apollos (Acts 18:26), she was violating another
cultural norm in which women did not teach or instruct men.
Over the next three centuries, these cultural conventions
became normative in church structures. Women were progressively
disempowered in the public proclamation of the Gospel and in exercising
authority within the churches.
It is a supreme irony that in early Christianity people were
scandalized by women's coequal leadership, while today people are
scandalized that women are not permitted to lead.
In my view, the obstacles to sacramentally ordaining women deacons
are not theological at all, but emanate from our flawed humanity's
embrace of patriarchy, sexism and misogyny.
This leads me to the encouraging part of Francis' exchange with the leaders of the world's sisters.
Contrary to some rather negative headlines,
Francis did not summarily dismiss the possibility of ever restoring the
female diaconate. Instead he said, "We will go ahead. After some time, I
may call the members of the commission to see what they have found."
I was pleased by Francis' cogent explanation that church teaching —
while rooted in revelation — is not static but develops over time.
"The way of understanding the faith today, after Vatican II, is
different than the way of understanding the faith before Vatican II," he
said. "Because there was a development of understanding."
Indeed.
A development of understanding about women's roles is exactly what is
occurring now. We are coming to a new awareness that the ban on female
ordination is not of God.
Cultural norms that subordinate women are no longer seen as part of
God's given order. Quite the opposite. Therefore, if church teaching
about governance and ordination derives from culturally sanctioned
female subordination, that teaching must develop and be transformed.
This is the work of the Spirit in our present moment.
That Francis named a key theological insight from Vatican II — that
doctrine is not static but develops and deepens over time — is
significant, helpful and hopeful.
The last two papacies assiduously avoided any mention of new
understandings of church teaching — especially around the so-called
"women's issues."
Yet church teaching has unmistakably developed and changed. We once
taught that slavery was moral, that people outside the Catholic Church
cannot be saved, and that Judaism was responsible for the death of
Christ. Now, Vatican II has given us new understandings
of religious liberty, the goodness to be found in non-Christian
religions, the primacy of conscience, and (believe it or not), the
participation of all the faithful in the exercise of ecclesial
infallibility.
From Lumen Gentium:
The entire body of the faithful, anointed as they are by the Holy One, cannot err in matters of belief. They manifest this special property by means of the whole peoples' supernatural discernment in matters of faith when "from the Bishops down to the last of the lay faithful" they show universal agreement in matters of faith and morals.
We are very far from "universal agreement" about the present Catholic
practice of excluding women from church governance and ordination.
It is time to exercise our own ecclesial infallibility by sharing our
views about "matters pertaining to the good of the church" with our
fellow parishioners, our priests and other church officials (Code of Canon Law 212.3).
Here is a website that can help: http://catholicwomendeacons.org/support/support.
By the power of the Spirit at work in us and in our leaders, our
sexist ecclesial structures will one day be healed and transformed.
[St. Joseph Sr. Christine Schenk, an NCR board member, served urban
families for 18 years as a nurse midwife before co-founding
FutureChurch, where she served for 23 years. Her recent book Crispina and Her Sisters: Women and Authority in Early Christianity
(Fortress, 2017) was awarded first place in History by the Catholic
Press Association. She holds master's degrees in nursing and theology.